Murder in the Church: The Killings at The Covenant School

Brenda and I attended a Christian elementary school very much like The Covenant School of Nashville, Tennessee.

Like the Covenant School, our school came from the heart of a local church who desired “to assist Christian parents and the Church by providing an exceptional academic experience founded upon and informed by the Word of God.”

Before Monday, March 27, 2023, few outside Nashville knew anything about the small, private, Christian school in Tennessee’s largest city. We wish the name was still unknown to us, but after the murders of three children and three staff members, our wish is impossible.

We should consider the murderer’s motives and her narrow hit list, her past connection to the school and her current identity as male. None of this is irrelevant. All of it reveals the deep depravity in the heart of humanity. Someone else can do that research and provide commentary. I want to head in a different direction.

Weep with Those Who Weep

I do not know anyone at The Covenant School nor at Covenant Presbyterian Church. Yet, I feel like I know them all because they are my brothers and sisters. I know the murdered nine-year-old girls. They exit minivans each Sunday morning and come into our church building. I know their moms and dads, their brothers and sisters. I know the three assassinated faculty. These faithful servants of our Lord died with him a long time ago when they gave themselves to Christian education. My mom was one of them. I’ve worked alongside them in the local church for many years.

The dead and the surviving are my people, and I am overcome with emotion – joy that the Lord has brought to himself those that are his and deep sorrow for parents without children, husbands without wives, brothers without sisters, aunts without nieces, a local church where every member is suffering, and dozens of young children whose innocence was shattered as gunfire rounds hit bodies near them.

For them I pray to our Father in heaven, that he would come to the aid of my brothers and sisters, that he would give them sleep at the end of the day, that he would, both now and in the days and years to come, remember them in their grief, that he whose son was murdered on a cross would extend never ending grace in all its aspects to those who lost at the hand of a murderer, that they would not lose heart in the promises of our God, and that they would be faithful to the end – for the glory of our God, for the testimony of the name of Jesus, and for the good of their souls.

Addressing My Confusion

To myself I turn to the Scriptures to try to make sense of what has happened to my brothers and sisters. I am drawn to Paul’s words to the Corinthian church, to the Holy Spirit’s words to our church, to the Spirit’s words to me.

But we have this treasure in jars of clay to show that this all-surpassing power is from God and not from us. We are hard pressed on every side, but not crushed; perplexed, but not in despair; persecuted, but not abandoned; struck down, but not destroyed. We always carry around in our body the death of Jesus, so that the life of Jesus may also be revealed in our body. For we who are alive are always being given over to death for Jesus’ sake, so that his life may also be revealed in our mortal body. So then, death is at work in us, but life is at work in you (2 Corinthians 4:7-12).

I can read “that the life of Jesus may also be revealed in our body.” May God grant grace to live it.

As always, thanks for reading, and I welcome your feedback and any suggestions you might have for an upcoming Lunchtime Musing.

Let's Get Ready to Rumble

What’s the hardest, most difficult, most exhausting, and most dangerous matter you will face today? Do you know the answer? It's the same answer for all of us. The answer is sin. There is no greater plague, no heavier burden, and no greater challenge before you today than sin. There is nothing with greater consequences and nothing that can bring you more pain. Sin offers nothing but momentary pleasure that metastasizes to deadly disease.

Today, you and I must fight against sin (Galatians 5:19-21).

  • Fight against idolatry.

  • Fight against envy.

  • Fight against lust.

  • Fight against immorality.

  • Fight against contentions.

  • Fight against lying.

  • Fight against cutting comments.

  • Fight against hateful thinking.

  • Fight against angry outbursts.

  • Fight against stealing.

  • Fight against jealousy.

  • Fight against meanness.

  • Fight against laziness.

  • Fight against addictions.

  • Fight against worry.

  • Fight against all attitudes and actions like any of these.

How Do We Fight Against Sin?

Start here, determine you will not sin. Remember Joseph living in Potiphar’s house? The text implies that she had been luring Joseph long before she propositioned him (Genesis 39:7). Joseph’s reply was a predetermined one. He was not going to sin with Potiphar’s wife. We do well to make a similar determination when we purpose not to sin. We articulate the purpose in statements like, “I will not have an angry outburst” and “I will not be argumentative.”

Take the steps the Bible advises. When sin presents itself…

  • Flee youthful lusts (2 Timothy 2:22).

  • Take to yourself the whole armor of God so you can withstand temptation (Ephesians 6:11).

  • Hide God’s Word in your heart so that you do not sin against God (Psalm 119:11).

You can win this fight, Christian, because you are a changed person. The Holy Spirit gave you a new nature at your new birth. Our God has released us from our captor. Part of our inheritance is freedom from sin. Now go live in your freedom.

As always, thanks for reading, and I welcome your feedback and any suggestions you might have for an upcoming Lunchtime Musing.

Why I Am Not Leaving Minnesota Anytime Soon

We all know former residents of our state who have left Minnesota for one reason or another. Here are the facts:

  • About 19,400 residents abandoned Minnesota between July 2021 and July 2022, according to the U.S. Census Bureau's 2022 population.

  • The number leaving the state was softened by 14,194 international migrations into the state. The state saw a net 5,206 migrations away from the area.

  • On net, the state gained 5,713 people, as 64,821 births outpaced 53,204 deaths, boosting population.

I too have a desire to leave Minnesota but not for the reason you might think. It’s no secret that I am not a fan of the cold. I never have been. As a child in Chicago, my hands and feet were always cold in the winter. My mom would bundle me in layers and put plastic bread bags on my feet inside my rubber boots.

We have had at least 1” of snow cover in the Twin Cities for more than 100 consecutive days with no end in sight. Today we woke to a morning temperature of 8 degrees. But the weather has nothing to do with why I want to leave Minnesota and nothing to do with why I am not leaving Minnesota anytime soon.

Minnesota has changed since I moved here at the turn of the century, and I want out. Both the data and anecdotes support my claim.

Minnesota’s Downward Spiral

Unlike many states, Minnesota government is flush with cash, to the tune of nearly $19 billion dollars. Our state legislature and our governor have no intention of returning the money to the people, and worse, have proposed tax increases on the citizenry. In a recent conversation with one of the hard-working men in our church, he expressed his frustration. He had recently completed his state income tax filing and owes the state a few hundred dollars. All year long his company has withheld his state taxes, but the withholding was not enough for our state. They demand he pay more. The few hundred dollars will mean nothing to the state but will be significant for this man. When he says, “I want out,” I sympathize with him.

Last week, our governor gloated for the cameras when he signed an executive order by which he commands access to so called “gender affirming care.” By the action, the governor has taken one more giant step to silence all dissenters who affirm there are only two genders and that puberty blockers and top and bottom surgery are immoral. When someone tells me they want to live in a different state where such wickedness is not promoted by the state government, I get it. I want out too.

Earlier this winter I watched from my living room window a bizarre scene. We live on a mostly quiet street in a mostly quiet neighborhood of a mostly quiet suburb. It was the middle of the day on a Saturday afternoon when an odd movement caught my attention.

Across the street from my house, a driver was trying to get his vehicle off a fire hydrant. He had taken the corner too fast, slid on the snow-covered road, and landed on top of the bright red plug. Forward to reverse, over and again, the car lurched but did not release from its captor. A few seconds later the man emerged from the car, walking away from the vehicle in the direction he came. That seemed odd. Why wouldn’t he stay with the vehicle waiting for someone to come help? He walked right in front of my house carrying a woman’s purse. That was all I needed to see. We called the police, and you guessed it, the vehicle was stolen and probably the purse too. The perp was getting away as fast as possible.

Carjackings are on the rise in Minnesota, so much so that our attorney general has launched an investigation into the car manufacturers.  Carjackers routinely use the vehicle while committing other crimes. Stealing cars for a joy ride is not the end goal, and carjackings are not the extent of violent crime in Minnesota. Recent killings at the Mall of America and a murder at St Paul’s Harding High School are the latest examples of an unsafe society. When people tell me they no longer go out after dark, I understand. When they say they want to move to a safer locale, maybe someplace rural, I get it. I want out too.

These are just a few of the changes in Minnesota over the last few decades. It’s not the same place where I raised my children. But I cannot leave, for the same reasons that Martin Luther and Martin Rinkart didn’t leave.

Shepherds Don’t Leave the Sheep

You know Martin Luther’s significant place in the Reformation, but do you remember that he was a pastor? And he pastored during a horrific time in European history. Briefly, the bubonic plague or Black Death raged across Europe before Luther’s time. Between 1347-1350, the plague killed one quarter of Europe’s population. The plague returned during Luther’s lifetime arriving in Wittenberg in 1527. Naturally, everyone who could leave the city did so as fast as they could. But not all could leave. Those without financial ability to relocate, those too ill to travel, and those with no place to go remained. Without holding hostage the consciences of any in the church, Martin and Katie Luther determined that they would stay despite the reality of the situation. They determined the brothers and sisters still in Wittenberg needed pastoral care. The unbelieving in the city needed a messenger of the gospel. At risk of their own health, they opened their home to the diseased and served those who remained. Shepherds don’t leave the sheep when trouble comes.

A century later Martin Rinkhart served as one of four pastors in Eilenburg, Germany. During his pastorate the Thirty Years’ War broke out. Historians teach that the Thirty Years’ War is the worst war ever fought on German soil, including the two World Wars. The war began in 1617. By 1637 the situation was so dire in Eilenburg that refugees fought in the streets over dead cats and birds. Dysentery and disease soon followed. The four pastors conducted ten or more funerals each day. Two of the pastors died from disease. The third fled for his life, leaving only Rinkhart to minister the Word of God to the city’s occupants. During his ministry, he conducted 4,480 funerals. His self-sacrifice is the stuff of legends. He gave away food and clothing, anything of his own possessions to relieve the suffering of the people he served. Later that same year, his wife died. He, however, survived the war and its aftermath. Shepherds don’t leave the sheep when trouble comes.

In 1636 Pastor Rinkhart wrote a hymn for his children to sing around the family meal, Now Thank We All Our God. All three verses are beautiful, but ponder with wonder the lines of the second.

O may this bounteous God
through all our life be near us,
with ever joyful hearts
and blessed peace to cheer us,
to keep us in his grace,
and guide us when perplexed,
and free us from all ills
of this world in the next.

I won’t be leaving Minnesota anytime soon. As long as the Lord wills, as long as the Lord’s people are in need of a pastor, as long as the lost in the Twin Cities need the gospel, and as long as God gives me voice and strength, I’m staying because shepherds don’t leave the sheep.

As always, thanks for reading, and I welcome your feedback and any suggestions you might have for an upcoming Lunchtime Musing.

Our Vanilla Flavored Christianity

Maybe the illustration doesn't work, but our Christianity is much more vanilla than it is 31 flavors. Most days are the same flavor. Only occasionally does a thrilling new flavor of the day enter our worlds. For most Christians most obedience is of the vanilla variety.

Here’s a thought exercise for Christians, “What acts of mundane obedience to our Lord do you strive to obey consistently?”

A Trip Down Memory Lane

It’s been a long forty years wandering around the desert, but finally, under new leadership, the descendants of Jacob are ready to enter the land God promised first to Abraham 500 years prior. The Old Testament book of Joshua records the taking and the occupying of the land.

The first twelve chapters read like a thriller. Page after page records over the top results as the people obey God when he instructs in extreme circumstances.

There is the river crossing when all the people with all their stuff obey God’s instruction to step into the swollen Jordan River with only the promise from God that he will hold back the raging waters. True to his word, the Lord brings his people to the other side after they obey him. It was the only time God directed them to cross a river without aid of bridge or transportation.

There is the complete annihilation of the Jericho fortress when the people oddly march around the walled city day after day, blowing trumpets on the last day, and finishing their battle plan with a unified shout. Then, Jericho’s walls fall. True to his word, the Lord defeats Israel’s enemies after they obeyed him. It was the only time God directed them to do laps around an enemy city.

Unusual commands lead to unusual outcomes until the land is conquered. Then comes the second half of Joshua. By contrast to part one, part two is B. O. R. I. N. G. The rest of Joshua reads like a plot book at the land surveyor’s office, “Their territory was Jazer, and all the cities of Gilead, and half the land of the Ammonites as far as Aroer, which is before Rabbah…”

Humdrum Acts of Obedience

Old Testament narrative writers use repetition to draw our attention to important ideas. The writer of Joshua uses the tool in chapter 14 when he records the distribution of the land, commenting, “As the Lord had commanded” (vv. 2, 5). The distribution of the land and the conquering of the land are two sides of the same coin. One side is flashy; the other is dull. One is exciting. The other is uninspiring. One side palpates the heart. The other side is mundane. Both are extremely important to the life of God’s people.

A Thought Exercise

Most of our obedience to our Lord is in the course of routine life. Occasionally, the Lord will ask us to do something unusual, but for most of us, obedience on March 7, 2023 does not look all that different from obedience to the Lord on March 7, 2022 or 2021 or 2020…

So, again, the question: “What acts of mundane obedience to our Lord do you strive to obey consistently?” Here are some of mine.

  • Tell the truth in all situations. The Bible says, “Put away lying; speak the truth” (Ephesians 4:25). Every day, I want to obey the Lord by only speaking the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. Truth telling is a mundane but vital act of obedience.

  • Gather with God’s people. The Bible says Christians must not neglect gathering together (Hebrews 10:25). With only the rarest of exceptions, I am committed to obeying Christ by joining the church when she comes together. Sunday church attendance is a mundane but vital act of obedience.

  • Restrain my tongue. To Christians the Bible says, “No foul language should come from your mouth” (Ephesians 4:29). Daily, I want to obey the Lord by refusing to use cuss words, words loaded with innuendo, or language that gives my verbiage a PG-13 rating. Refraining from foul language is a mundane but vital act of obedience.

There are more, but you get the idea. Curiously, the amount of space in the book of Joshua given to the mundane distribution of the land in obedience to God is similar to the amount of space given to acts of obedience that bring the conquest of the land by miraculous events. It is almost like the Holy Spirit wishes to emphasize to us the importance of mundane obedience to the commands of God.

If you have been a Christian for any amount of time, you realize that following the leadership of our Lord Jesus Christ is mostly monochrome. Eugene Peterson calls our discipleship “A long obedience in the same direction.” That sounds right. Our obedience to Christ today will likely look very similar to yesterday, and our obedience to Christ next week will not be much different than our obedience to Christ this week.

To what mundane acts of obedience are you committed? Not sure? Identify a Bible text and connect your routine obedience to it. It’s that simple…ordinary…mundane, but exactly what Christ calls us to.

May God grant us all daily grace to live “as the Lord had commanded.”

As always, thanks for reading, and I welcome your feedback and any suggestions you might have for an upcoming Lunchtime Musing.

My Top Two Parent Practices

Young parents do a lot of dumb things. I know because I was one. I think I could go on for hours about the dumb stuff I did when our boys and girls were in diapers or learning to drive. I’d like to think most of the errors were made in ignorance. In my defense, this was my first time being a parent. I didn’t know what I didn’t know, and what I thought I knew wasn’t what I knew. It’s complicated.

On the other hand, in God’s grace there were some things we got right. Brenda may recall, but I do not - somewhere along the way we picked up two critical practices we incorporated into our parenting. These are at the top of our list of what parents must teach and expect of their children.

  1. First Time Obedience

We have a good Heavenly Father. His instructions are neither grievous nor arbitrary. When he speaks to us, he expects us to obey, the first time we are told and without hesitation or complaint.

What God expects of all humanity is what he directs in parent / child relationships. He says, “Children, obey your parents,” but small children cannot read. The Word of God must be read to them and taught to them. Obedience to parents is the first instruction of God a child needs to learn and a parent needs to teach. When we teach our children to obey parents, we are training our children how to respond to God – immediately and without complaint.

Obedience is a submission of the will. We humble ourselves before God who has the authority to direct. In his wisdom, God has delegated authority in the home to parents. Curiously, all too many parents have abdicated their positions and handed them over to four, five, and six-year-olds. We’ve all seen the meltdown when a child does not get his way. We’ve all witnessed a 28-pound, cute as a button, curly haired princess control the actions of four fully grown humans. It’s only funny when it’s not your kid.

To gain compliance, many parents resort to negotiation tactics. Remember longstanding political policy, “We do not negotiate with terrorists”? Your child is not a terrorist, but we do not negotiate with children to gain their compliance. Negotiation teaches authority can be shared and gained by tactics and ploys. This is not God’s wisdom for your home.

When children resist parental instruction, ask the child, “Are you going to obey God by obeying mom…dad?” The question elevates the problem to the real issue: this is not first a power struggle between the child and the parent but a power struggle between the child and God. Junior is faced with his responsibility before God. His repeated failures to obey God open the door for gospel answers. “I don’t know why I can’t obey” turns to “You cannot, but Jesus did.”

The earlier you institute this expectation in your home, the better. Forming patterns of obedience is easier than breaking patterns of disobedience. Still, if you have not taught your older children what God requires, it is not too late. Seek God’s forgiveness for missing the mark, communicate with your children what God expects, then graciously and patiently enforce God’s expectation. Your children will be better for it.

When we do not require first time obedience, we teach our children that parental authority is arbitrary and by extension, God’s authority is arbitrary too. First time obedience is not a sign of weakness but an expression of maturity that understands I am not the king of my world. God is, and I will obey him.

    2. A Righteous, Verbal Response

We’ve all witnessed it, the exasperated parent who belts out, “How many times do I have to tell you not to do that?” and “This is the 100th time I’ve told you this, and you still haven’t done it.” And we know the adolescent responses, “I didn’t hear you” or “I didn’t understand what you meant” or “I thought you wanted me to do something else.” That’s a tricky situation in parent / child relationships. You might have your suspicions, but how do you know your children didn’t hear you or how do you know your child understood your direction? The requirement of righteous, verbal response positions the child for obedience. All three words are important.

Righteous

“Yes ma’am” is a response. So is a sigh, a slammed door, or stomping away. The latter responses are natural. A righteous response is taught.

Our oldest never, and I mean never, told us no when we gave him an instruction. He “was more cunning than any” of the other children. When his mom gave him a directive, he would routinely tell us of his sudden leg pain. Rubbing his pants, he would offer, “My leg hurts.” The translation is, “Yeah, I’m not going to do that right now.” His younger sister, on the other hand, would look you square in the eye and tell you, “No!”

Verbal

How do you overcome the “I didn’t hear you” and the “I didn’t know that’s what you meant” and the rest? A parent needs to hear the child’s submission to authority and his acknowledgment that he understands the assignment.

Response

Each family must decide what works best for them. For us, we wanted something less formal than “Yes, sir” and “No, ma’am.” In our home, a righteous, verbal response is “Yes, dad,” “No, dad,” “Yes, mom,” and “No, mom.” When all was going well, the child offered this freely. On days when the flesh was stronger, we would ask for the response. “Will you give a righteous, verbal response?”

I am convinced a righteous, verbal response follows the pattern of Jesus. Do you remember his garden prayer? “Nevertheless not my will, but yours, be done.” Determine the righteous, verbal response that works best for your home, then stick to it.

Being a parent is great, but parenting is hard. Our God has given us the responsibility to train our children. Training for first time obedience and a righteous, verbal response honors the Lord.

Keep at it, parents. Your labor is not in vain.

As always, thanks for reading, and I welcome your feedback and any suggestions you might have for an upcoming Lunchtime Musing.